ACT and SAT: Eight Major Differences
ACT and SAT: eight major differences
1) ACT includes trigonometry; SAT does not.
2) ACT includes “science reasoning”, which is logical reasoning based on data and scientific terms, but not based on classroom science.
3) SAT deducts points for wrong answers. However with coaching, students can actually use this to their ADVANTAGE.
4) SAT Math demands scrutinizing the English aspect of math questions. ACT is more straightforward, making it a more comfortable test, but not necessarily easier. ACT math can include logarithms, high level exponent problems, and matrices; SAT does not.
5) SAT directly tests vocabulary. This rewards students who are big readers or good vocabulary absorbers.
6) SAT Reading is generally less interesting and the answers rely more on nuance.
7) SAT requires a 25 minute essay. ACT’s essay (30 min.) is optional now.
7A) Optional essays typically mean a student with high aims must do them or look like a laggard. The optional ACT essay will typically ask about familiar “school-related” things that American teens are familiar with: “should dress codes be used in school?”, “ should students receive academic credit for community service?” , and “should varsity athletes be allowed a less-demanding class load?” are among the recent ACT topics.
SAT essay topics are typically philosophical: “Are there heroes in the modern world?”, “is effort involved in pursuing any goal valuable?”, “should people prefer new ideas or values to those of the past?”, and “is there value for people to belong only to groups in which they have something in common?” were recent SAT prompts.
8) One difference that could be considered “major” is colleges’ USE of the SAT vs ACT: Almost all colleges “cherry-pick” SAT sub-scores, meaning they consider the best combination of Math, CR and Writing earned on different dates. Only a minority of the “most competitive” colleges do this with the four ACT sub-scores. Thus, a student who does not ping strong scores on all ACT sections on the same day, is being dragged down by one or more weaker sections, whereas cherry-picking SAT scores means one weak section on one day does not hurt.
Our suggestions:
Make an early comparison. Buy The Official SAT Study Guide ISBN # 087447-852-5 and take any two of the first three full length tests under timed conditions.
Buy The Real ACT Prep Guide ISBN # 07689-3440-0 and take any two of the five tests therein under timed conditions. Score them and use the accompanying table to compare the non-Writing sections (1600 SAT scale) with one another.
If you really need to save time, you need not do the Writing sections for either
(they compare almost the same). SAT's two multiple choice Writing Sections and ACT's first section ("English") are almost the same. And the Essay (Section 1 on an SAT and the last section on the ACT) are almost the same. Students may skip these sections and thereby save time. SAT thus becomes a six-section test (2.5 hours) and ACT becomes a three section test (2.25 hours).
Absent a comparison (or if the comparison shows nearly identical scores): most students seeking admission to competitive colleges who are capable of absorbing vocabulary should study for SAT and disregard ACT if scores are strong. Add ACT prep if after two post-tutoring SATs the scores are unlikely to impress your target colleges.
Our equally important suggestion: START EARLY. Colleges credit the best score, so it’s important to have three or more opportunities to take these tests. With vacations, proms, and graduations, that means the students who plan in advance will have the best opportunities. This is especially true for families that want to take advantage of Early Decision. For students who’ve had a semester each of
Algebra and Geometry by the end of sophomore year, the summer before junior year and/or the fall of junior year are usually the best times to prep.
ACT vs. SAT Summary as of August 2012
“English” “Writing”
Essay 30 min (optional, at end) Essay 25 min (required, at beginning)
Grammar Grammar
60 min 75 questions 35 min 49 questions
Math Math
60 min 60 questions 70 min 54 questions
Need trigonometry, matrices No trigonometry, logs, matrices, and complex numbers or complex numbers
Reading “Critical Reading”
35 min 40 questions 70 min 67 questions
4 passages 4 passages + 19 Sentence Completion questions.
Science reasoning
35 min 40 questions no science
7 experiments
Equating Section Equating section
No equating section 25 min Math, Reading, or Writing
3 hrs 10 min + 30min optional writing 3 hrs 45 min
Approx 25 min extraneous time Approx 45 min extraneous time
$35 + $15 if doing Writing $49
Superscoring – still a minority of the Superscoring – by almost all colleges; most competitive colleges Univ of Calif are 10 of the 12 exceptions
"Score Choice” - yes “Score Choice” – yes
Score Choice is not being adhered to by many colleges, which are asking to see all scores. However, all these colleges claim to assess students on their best
scores.
Bottom Line: the tests are similar. No college requires one over the other, and to our knowledge, no college has a preference. ACT remains a bit broader in content. ACT to a slight degree tests knowledge a bit more than resourcefulness. Knowledge AND resourcefulness are “coach-able”.
***********************************************************************************************************
Ivy Bound / Rising Scores offers tutoring and
ACT / SAT Prep classes in 21 states. Ivy
Bound instructors include college students, grad students, and seasoned school
teachers who have all scored among the top 1% on the SAT or ACT. Ivy Bound’s flexibility appeals to many busy
students and parents. The group is able
to hold classes in any community and is often invited to hold classes in
schools that have been underserved by some of the larger test prep
organizations. Most Ivy Bound SAT prep classes are held on weekends at schools,
churches, synagogues, & community centers.
Ivy Bound also holds small classes in parents’ homes where a parent or
student garners students with similar schedules and similar abilities. Ivy Bound offers private and semi-private
tutoring for the SAT, ACT, SAT II and most AP tests.
*********************************************************************************
Below is a list from Jennifer Tabbushof Los-Angeles-based Headed For College of colleges that are super-scoring the ACT as of fall 2010:
California
Institute of Technology
California
State University System
North
Carolina State University
Franklin
W. Olin College of Engineering
Rose-Hulman Institute of Technology
University
of Arkansas – Fayetteville
University
of Colorado – Boulder
University
of Louisiana – Lafayette
University of
Tennessee – Knoxville
Washington
University – St. Louis
ACT and
SAT: eight major differences
1) ACT includes trigonometry; SAT does
not.
2) ACT includes “science reasoning”,
which is logical reasoning based on data and scientific terms, but not based on
classroom science.
3) SAT deducts points for wrong
answers. However with coaching, students
can actually use this to their ADVANTAGE.
4) SAT Math demands scrutinizing the English aspect of math questions. ACT is more straightforward, making it a more
comfortable test, but not necessarily easier. ACT math can include logarithms, high level
exponent problems, and matrices; SAT does not.
5) SAT directly tests vocabulary. This rewards students who are big readers or good
vocabulary absorbers.
6) SAT Reading is generally less
interesting and the answers rely more on nuance.
7) SAT requires a 25 minute
essay. ACT’s essay (30 min.) is optional now.
7A) Optional essays typically mean a
student with high aims must do them or look like a laggard. The optional ACT essay will typically ask
about familiar “school-related” things
that American teens are familiar with: “should dress codes be used in
school?”, “ should students receive
academic credit for community service?” , and “should varsity athletes be
allowed a less-demanding class load?” are among the recent ACT topics.
SAT essay topics are typically
philosophical: “Are there heroes in the modern world?”, “is effort involved in
pursuing any goal valuable?”, “should people prefer new ideas or values to
those of the past?”, and “is there value for people to belong only to groups in
which they have something in common?” were recent SAT prompts.
8) One difference that could be
considered “major” is colleges’ USE of the SAT vs ACT: Almost all colleges
“cherry-pick” SAT sub-scores, meaning they consider the best combination of
Math, CR and Writing earned on different dates.
Only a minority of the “most competitive” colleges do this with the four
ACT sub-scores. Thus, a student who does
not ping strong scores on all ACT sections on the same day, is being dragged
down by one or more weaker sections, whereas cherry-picking SAT scores means
one weak section on one day does not hurt.
Our suggestions:
Make
an early comparison. Buy The Official
SAT Study Guide ISBN # 087447-852-5 and take any two of the first three
full length tests under timed conditions.
Buy The Real ACT Prep Guide ISBN # 07689-3440-0 and take any two of
the five tests therein under timed conditions.
Score them and use the accompanying table to compare the non-Writing
sections (1600 SAT scale) with one another.
If
you really need to save time, you need not do the Writing sections for either
(they compare almost the same). SAT's
two multiple choice Writing Sections and ACT's first section
("English") are almost the same. And the Essay (Section 1 on an
SAT and the last section on the ACT) are almost the same. Students
may skip these sections and thereby save time. SAT thus becomes a
six-section test (2.5 hours) and ACT becomes a three section test (2.25 hours).
Absent a comparison (or if the
comparison shows nearly identical scores): most students seeking admission to
competitive colleges who are capable of absorbing vocabulary should study for
SAT and disregard ACT if scores are strong.
Add ACT prep if after two post-tutoring SATs the scores are unlikely to
impress your target colleges.
Our equally important suggestion:
START EARLY. Colleges credit the best
score, so it’s important to have three or more opportunities to take these
tests. With vacations, proms, and
graduations, that means the students who plan in advance will have the best
opportunities. This is especially true
for families that want to take advantage of Early Decision. For students who’ve had a semester each of
Algebra and Geometry by the end of sophomore year, the summer before junior year and/or the fall of junior year are
usually the best times to prep.
ACT vs. SAT Summary
as of August 2012
“English” “Writing”
Essay 30 min (optional, at end) Essay 25 min
(required, at beginning)
Grammar Grammar
60
min 75
questions 35
min 49 questions
Math Math
60
min 60
questions 70
min 54 questions
Need
trigonometry, matrices No
trigonometry, logs, matrices, or complex numbers
matrices
and Complex numbers
Reading “Critical Reading”
35
min
40 questions 70 min 67
questions
4
passages 4
passages + 19 Sentence Completion questions.
Science
reasoning
35
min 40
questions no
science
7
experiments
Equating
Section Equating section
No
equating section 25 min Math, Reading, or Writing
3
hrs 10 min + 30min optional writing 3
hrs 45 min
Approx
25 min extraneous time Approx 45 min extraneous
time
$35
+ $15 if doing Writing $49
Superscoring – still a minority of the Superscoring – by almost all colleges; Univ of Calif are
most
competitive colleges. 10 of the 12 exceptions
“Score Choice” - yes “Score Choice” – yes
Score Choice is not being adhered to by many
colleges, which are asking to see all scores.
However, all these colleges claim to assess students on their best
scores.
Bottom Line:
the tests are similar. No college
requires one over the other, and to our knowledge, no college has a preference.
ACT remains a bit broader in content.
ACT to a slight degree tests knowledge a bit more than resourcefulness. Knowledge AND resourcefulness are
“coach-able”.
***********************************************************************************************************
Ivy Bound / Rising Scores offers tutoring and
ACT / SAT Prep classes in 21 states. Ivy
Bound instructors include college students, grad students, and seasoned school
teachers who have all scored among the top 1% on the SAT or ACT. Ivy Bound’s flexibility appeals to many busy
students and parents. The group is able
to hold classes in any community and is often invited to hold classes in
schools that have been underserved by some of the larger test prep
organizations. Most Ivy Bound SAT prep classes are held on weekends at schools,
churches, synagogues, & community centers.
Ivy Bound also holds small classes in parents’ homes where a parent or
student garners students with similar schedules and similar abilities. Ivy Bound offers private and semi-private
tutoring for the SAT, ACT, SAT II and most AP tests.
*********************************************************************************
M:\Articles\ACT vs SAT 2010-11.doc
Below
is a list from Jennifer Tabbushof Los-Angeles-based Headed For College of colleges that are super-scoring the ACT as
of fall 2010:
California
Institute of Technology
California
State University System
North
Carolina State University
Franklin
W. Olin College of Engineering
Rose-Hulman Institute of Technology
University
of Arkansas – Fayetteville
University
of Colorado – Boulder
University
of Louisiana – Lafayette
University of
Tennessee – Knoxville
Washington
University – St. Louis
Buzz Beeler
8:57 am on Monday, August 13, 2012
Incredible, this is the most comprehensive blog post with such insightful information that I have ever seen. It's a shame that with all the work that went into this, that Jenna does not use her full name. The person that wrote this deserves full credit for this post as well as Marge Neal does for editing it.
Mark Greenstein
12:54 pm on Thursday, September 6, 2012
Thank you for the praise. Jenna and I appreciate your comments. We want to make the admissions process more clear. Many guidance counselors are not candid about the importance of grades and SAT scores. They don't want a student to feel bad or be disappointed; but in the meantime, the students who DO KNOW what's expected for a top-tier admission march ahaead of the kids who are comforted with "feel good" as they fall behind.
Mark Greenstein